Last Updated on March 2, 2010 by FERS Disability Attorney
I am often asked whether or not a medical report from the “specialist” will have a greater impact than a family doctor. Implied in such a question, of course, is a perspective which tends to see the family doctor as somehow “less qualified”, sort of like comparing the technical deficiencies of a “country doctor” as opposed to a “real doctor” — one who works in an emergency room in a large metropolitan hospital. Perspectives and prejudices have a way of defining judgments, and assumptions, presumptions and long-held beliefs, whether valid or not, often rule our lives.
How can I answer such questions? In the course of a Hearing before an Administrative Judge at the Merit Systems Protection Board, I have had family doctors testify who were unbeatable, and certainly overwhelming in his or her expertise and medical knowledge. The years of experience in having to deal with thousands of patients, and confronting and treating medical conditions of every imaginable sort — and making decisions (including referring patients to “specialists” for concurring or confirming diagnoses and opinions) involving the “whole” patient’s medical condition and treatment — came through with such persuasive force and overwhelming confidence, that it was indeed the “family doctor” or the “country doctor” who ruled the day.
Similarly, I have had the “specialist” testify in cases, who barely were able to coherently describe the connection between the medical condition and the essential elements of the job. And, of course, sometimes the opposite is true — good surgeon, mediocre family doctor; mediocre specialist, great country doctor. As in all things, in Federal Disability Retirement applications under FERS or CSRS, it is not so much that the credentials matter, as the character, experience, and “heart” of the doctor who treats the patient.
Sincerely,
Robert R. McGill, Esquire
Related
Tags:
a personal medical report or just filling out the sf 3112c,
advising your treating doctor about your opm disability application,
civil service disability retirement,
describing the applicable symptoms in the usps disability application,
differentiating symptoms and conditions in an opm narrative report,
disability retirement at the USPS,
explaining relationship of disability with job performance,
explaining the "nexus" as one of the most important issues in the medical report,
explaining to your doctor the importance of explaining the "nexus",
federal disability law blog,
federal disability lawyer,
FERS disability retirement,
FERS medical retirement,
legal representation for disability retirement federal workers pittsburgh pa,
medical and surgical treatments in opm disability decisions,
medical disability federal workers in new orleans la,
medical documentation from the chiropractor's office,
nationwide representation of federal employees,
nurse practitioners and federal disability retirement,
OPM Disability and the Ideal Doctor and Patient Relationship,
OPM disability retirement,
opm medical diagnosis and treatments,
owcp dol,
owcp keeping your doctor on your side,
postal service disability retirement,
representing federal employees from any us government agency,
representing federal employees in and outside the country,
statements from nurses in federal disability compensation cases,
the medical authority of an experienced family doctor in opm disability claims,
the relationship between a person's medical condition and the type of work which he or she engages in,
the relationship of the federal job and the medical condition,
the significance of symptoms in fers medical disability,
the symptoms and the diagnosis in the narrative report,
using chiropractors for your federal disability retirement application,
using the family doctor or a medical specialist during the mspb hearing,
USPS disability retirement