Last Updated on August 20, 2022 by FERS Disability Attorney
How does one “prove” a standard of “incompatibility”?
Physical injuries often allow for a medical opinion to impose certain restrictions: No lifting more than X-pounds; no standing more than 2 hours within an 8-hour period, etc. These, then, can directly “prove” that a Federal or Postal employee is no longer able to perform one or more of the essential or basic elements of one’s Federal or Postal Service job, by comparing such restrictions as against the positional requirements of a given job, and “showing” that the standard required can no longer be met.
The “other” cousin of the standard, as reiterated by cases represented by Henderson v. OPM and related precedents, allow for a “different” type of proof, where one may show that there is a general incompatibility between the entirety of one’s position and the medical conditions one suffers from.
It might be argued that such a standard is more “nebulous” and “harder to prove”, but in fact, the opposite is often true: specificity on a 1-to-1 ratio between a given medical condition or symptom and an element of one’s positional duties no longer becomes necessary. Rather, a general showing of incompatibility between the “type” of job and the “nature” of a medical condition is enough to qualify for Federal Disability Retirement.
The trick, of course, lies in the manner of “proving” it, but it should be of some comfort to Federal and Postal employees that there is another type of standard beyond the 1-to-1 ratio standard that applies generally for “physical” duties; for, in the end, many psychiatric conditions can only meet the “incompatibility” standard, although some specificity of inability to perform a particular function of the job may be present as well.
To meet either standard is a burden of proof that must be shown by the appellant in all OPM Disability Retirement cases; to understand, apply and satisfy such standards, it is best to consult with an attorney who specializes in Federal Disability Retirement Law.
Sincerely,
Robert R. McGill, Esquire
Tags:
alternatives after second opinion dr hired by dol sends you back to work with a disability,
applying for a disability retirement under fers after removal – you have only one year after separation,
can you retire medically from a government position? yes you do,
csrs retirement after proposed removal for medical unfit to work,
disability for federal government employees for non work related injuries,
disability retirement due to a service connected disability,
doctor letter to support my owcp disability retirement claim,
fed employee medical retirement for ptsd,
federal employee medical hardship retirement owcp.gov.com,
federal employee physician statement,
federal employee return to work physical exam,
federal government retirement letter due to medical reasons,
federal medical disability resignation letter,
fers disability retirement and 100% ptsd,
fers disability retirement application,
fers government job medical disqualification after employment,
fers letter of resignation due to disability,
fers medical inability to perform removal,
how does a medical removal from service affect fers retirement,
how long does a proposed medical removal take va,
how to quit federal job due to medical reasons,
keeping same health insurance under federal disability retirement,
light duty vs disability retirement for federal employees,
medical retirement bop,
medical retirement from federal government with asthma,
medical retirement in lieu of removal opm after failing fit for duty,
multiple sclerosis and retirement disability form the government,
opm and workmans comp after surgery,
opm lwop disability retirement,
opm medical leave of absence extended indefinable,
opm medical retirement disability package,
opm plantar fasciitis and approved reason,
opm termination of employment due to disabilities,
physician statement of disability opm,
ptsd police opm retirement,
reasonable accommodation opm disability retirement for employees us government,
related to medicine fers disability retirement,
request for reconsideration opm disability retirement lawyer,
resign from federal service due medical reasons,
sf 3112b disability retirement form doc preparation,
start medical process for leave without pay for government workers,
u.s. postal worker disability retirement,
us dept of labor owcp early and permanent disability retirement,
usps and medical pensions federal retirement disability attorneys in cincinnati oh,
usps disability retirement anxiety,
usps return to work but unable medical reason,
what constitutes the 80% salary cap for disability retirement? that means if you make more than 80% of what you used to make you may lose fers disability retirement forever,
will opm take the advice of the doctor for disability retirement? doctor needs to understand eligibility rules for opm (which are different than ssa) and thus an opinion is usually not enough
4 thoughts on “Federal & Postal Disability Retirement: Standard of incompatibility”