Last Updated on July 26, 2022 by FERS Disability Attorney
In many questions, there are multiple sub-questions. Take, for example, the question: Why are you so tired? You may respond first by answering the unasked but implicit question by declaring: “But I am not tired”. That is not what the question asked. Such an answer is a response to the implied question within the question, of: “Are you tired?” To the question actually asked, the proper response might be: I stayed up late last night reading. The presumptive sub-question unstated and silent but implicit in the major question posited in duality of a contingent combination, is precisely what is often termed as “lawyerly”, and thus somehow deceitful, tricky and attempting to subvert by having the responder accept a non-explicit presumption of facts.
The classic example, of course, is the cross-examination query stated variously as: “When did you stop beating your wife?” Before an objection is launched, the unwary witness might respond, “I didn’t” – meaning (from the witness’ perspective) that he never beat his wife in the first place, when in fact such a response evokes a different meaning – that the individual never stopped beating his wife, and continues to do so up until the present. There is, in such a duality of question/sub-question combination, the presumptive prefatory inquiry, stated as: “Have you ever beaten your wife?”
It is, in many ways, the capacity and ability to dissect and recognize the need to bifurcate or even trifurcate linguistic bundles that require thought, reflection and insightful methodologies in order to help define existence as successful or otherwise challenging. Life is a tough road to forge; language opens the world by allowing for avenues and pathways of communication, but it also compels constructing obstacles that deflect and defeat the reality of Being surrounding us.
In the linear historicity of language and the explosion of thought, conceptual paradigms and communication inventories, the commingling of questions, the looseness of language and the careless ways in which thoughts are provoked, may lend itself to confusion, puzzlement and an inability to solve problems. That is, of course, the strength of argument impounded by the British Empiricists, and while their collective denial of any substantive issues inherent in philosophical problems is itself suspect, their contribution in attempting to identify peripheral, “non-substantive” issues arising from the imprecise usage of language, in contradistinction to central and essential conundrums, helps us all.
For Federal employees and U.S. Postal workers who are preparing to formulate a Federal Disability Retirement application through the U.S. Office of Personnel Management, whether the Federal or Postal employee is under FERS, CSRS or CSRS Offset, a word to the wise: SF 3112A contains multiple implicit questions, and bifurcation – nay, trifurcation – is an important element to consider and resolve. Be cognizant of the implicit question – lest you answer the major question without considering the prefatory query. Standard Forms are replete with compound questions, and the unwary will inevitably fall into the trap of answering the question posed on the surface, and in so doing, admit to facts presumptively “hidden” in sub-questions unasked.
Preparing an OPM Disability Retirement application requires the effort of untangling such compounding and confounding queries; it is up to the unwary Federal or Postal employee to bifurcate and trifurcate such attempts, and to dissect, with precision of purpose, the questions unasked, and answer those which are both prefatory and sequential.
Sincerely,
Robert R. McGill, Esquire
Tags:
agency denying reasonable accommodation for federal workers,
cervical disc federal workplace,
clinical assessment and current prognosis of the specified medical condition(s) and plans for future treatments,
difference between opm regular retirement and owcp retirement,
difference between opm retirement and owcp retirement: owcp is not a retirement system but in this case you as a fed employee you may qualify for opm disability retirement,
disabled federal employee representative for benefits,
doctor to examine a federal injured employee,
dod civilian depression medical retirement,
dod civilian medical retirement,
dod firefighter medical retirement law firm,
does my agency have to restore my used sick leave time prior disability retirement?,
empathy for federal government co-workers with disabilities,
epa disabled retiree,
federal disability retirement anxiety,
federal employee asperger's syndrome and medical retirement,
federal employee owcp pre-existing conditions qualify for disability retirement?,
federal employee with ptsd,
federal technician disability application,
fers disability retirement depression,
fers owcp disability for ptsd,
government fers medical retirement forms help,
help for appeal stage of opm disability retirement,
help with the ri30-1 opm medical questionnaire form for continuation of benefits,
how to file a lawsuit against owcp and if I should use my limited financial resources for fers disability retirement instead,
how to file federal technician disability application,
if i get approved for federal workers comp can I still apply for disability retirement?,
if I get fired due to a medical condition will I get disability retirement any way? not necessarily and in fact they’ll try to deny ask atty free first time consultation,
important front letter narration opm disability,
legal assistance for letter from doctor to claim federal disability retirement and other document preparation,
medical retirement from federal government,
medical retirement from federal government employment,
medical retirement from postal service,
modified job offer and real accommodation for fers disability retirement purposes,
my federal medical retirement was denied even though I was fired due to my medical condition,
narration of a disability claim opm letter,
on 60% fers now ssdi how much to pay back fers,
opm awol because of disability,
opm disability lawyer serving kentucky residents,
opm disabled employee being threatened,
opm fers disability claim,
opm gov bullying causing stress and anxiety,
opm hostile work environment guidance for federal employees with pending medical pension applications,
opm medical retirement forms,
opm owcp disability attorneys serving phoenix az residents,
opm workers comp repetitive motion,
owcp and worsening of medical condition,
owcp lawyer in ms,
post office hostile work environment causing mental conditions in employees,
postal employee claiming carpal tunnel work and other illnesses,
postal medical retirement process,
prove disability retirement after resignation federal employment,
reasons for opm disability retirement,
rheumatoid arthritis owcp and fers,
san antonio medical retirement attorneys,
separated employee with csrs offset with ssd,
social security or staying on owcp for life? workers comp is not a retirement system and it will terminate (wrong question to begin with),
steps and process to initiating medical retirement opm,
stress depression claims federal dol medical retirement,
submitting current clinical findings from a recent physical or mental examination to opm,
updating medical documentation since retirement of the specific medical condition(s) which required you to retire,
usps awol and lwop medical reasons,
usps disability retirement process,
usps light duty disability retirement benefits,
usps policy on hostile work environment causing disability,
va employee disability retirement,
when there is a recurrence of owcp accepted condition